Hannah Sassaman — Banned from the National Association of Broadcasters Since 2002

The FCC Needs A Better Paper Shredder, Please Send In Your Comments Engraved on Sheet Metal Or Something
September 19, 2006, 3:53 pm
Filed under: fcc, radio, rants

As anyone with a passing familiarity with me, this blog, or Prometheus Radio Project likely knows by now, the Federal Communications Commission was caught hiding some research that we would have loved to have seen in 2003, or anytime after the FCC closed its public comment window on whether or not they should consolidate media ownership in the United States. The FCC, anytime between 2003 and today, could have released two studies that were conducted by staff at the Commission — one that demonstrates that locally owned TV stations devote an additional 20 to 25 percent of their newscasts to local news stories than stations owned by distant conglomerates — and another that shows how sharply the number of individual radio station owners fell when Congress passed the Telecommunications Act of 1996, widely seen as the most recent and most drastic cause of a paucity of decency, localism, and simple, traditional journalism in American broadcast media.

Why didn’t the FCC, under former Chairman Michael Powell and under current Chariman Kevin Martin, release these studies? Because they demonstrate clearly what Powell and Martin have tried hard to disprove to the courts and Congress (though not to the American people — that when local communities lose local control of their media outlets, their access to the basic tools of democracy falls to the floor.

That’s not a new message — over three million people told the commission, in detail, how deeply it would suck if Clear Channel owned all the stations in their town. Not only would access to our own city councils, schools, and churches dwindle, but our neighbors would lose their jobs, coverage of issues of interest to various minority groups would get a lot worse, and in the event of a disaster, diverse local coverage would become even less local and more consolidated.

Today, Martin finally bent to Boxer’s pressure, ordering a formal study into why the internal reports were shredded, but my instinct is that we should push for a lot more. I’ve been scrabbling with incredible local groups in Senate Commerce districts, groups like Reclaim the Media, in the heart of Seantor Maria Cantwell’s district, to see if any Senators who voted against the poorly-argued and widely-reviled media ownership consolidation package in 2003 would also vote to hold Martin’s renomination until he committed to much more than an official internal study as to why the reports were deep-sixed.

My thinking is this. For low power FM radio, community advocates, churches, civil rights groups, and more had to wait over three years for a study — an independent study commissioned -by- the FCC rather than conducted internally — to clear the way for more low power FM radio stations to be built in America’s big cities, where the broadcast lobby has successfully forbidden them for over six years, despite pressure from the Commission itself and an overwhelming amount of evidence that there is plenty of room for LPFM. We have to battle in Congress now to expand low power FM to America’s big cities, but in the scheme of things, undoing the congressional restriction on LPFM is just a matter of time, because we have an independent study conducted by a third party proving we are right, and thousands of community organizations lined up and fighting for their voice on the airwaves.

What would the same strategy look like for media ownership? We could freeze the media ownership proceeding almost indefinitely if we were waiting for an independent government contractor like MITRE to study the impacts of ownership. This would open a huge amount of time for community members to comment, for local economic studies to be produced and filed onto the docket as well — evidence which is infinitely more valuable not just on the ownership docket but for us as a movement, as we will hear from more and more of our communities the longer they have an official opportunity to make an impact.

In my opinion, the time is ripe to ask for an independent study, conducted by a third party organization, taking as long as necessary to get us guidelines for future regulation of media ownership. If we ask the Senate and the House to force the FCC to commission an independent study on the effects of consolidation — just like Congress did for low power FM — we might change how the FCC regulates media ownership, perhaps breaking the back of the recent trend towards deregulation, consolidation, and a shut-down of community voices.

Because we happen to be right in this case — because whatever evidence the industry tosses onto the record is likely to be baseless and hollow — I don’t see why we wouldn’t want the proceeding to take 2-3 years — as long as it takes the FCC to commission an independent study of
consolidation’s true effects.

While this is going on, and because we now have an extra month to file comments on the current media ownership proceeding (until December 21st), we need to be pushing to make sure that as many comments as possible get into this docket. One way that Prometheus discussed in its recent statement on the last shredded study that came to light was to make sure that the brilliant, diverse, and evidence-heavy comments filed onto the FCC’s localism docket are combined with the media ownership docket of 2006. As the lawyers at the Media Access Project always tell us — the FCC and the laywers representing us can always use clear stories describing how consolidation impacted their communities to push for specific rule changes. The localism docket is packed with comments like that, from Hawaii to Maine.

I heard a rumour that the long-overdue FCC cable ownership proceeding would be included in the current package of broadcast ownership rules the FCC is looking at on 06-121. That means that the testimony being collected by projects like Free the Flyers (by my friend Josh Breitbart) which is gathering microlocal information about how cable consolidation is hurting people in Philadelphia, my hometown, could impact how the FCC regulates cable here and around the country, if it is submitted to the Commission. Other powerful projects like Youth Media Council’s community review of KMEL, the People’s Station, and the media monitoring of the Media Empowerment Project‘s initiatives in North Carolina, Detroit, and San Antonio, could give the FCC the wherewithal to change how the market looks in those communities, just by the FCC taking the data that their communities have already gathered into account.

I feel like these reports, buried by the Commission but coming to light just as they try again to prove the impossible — are tools that our movement can’t afford to wield incorrectly, and without the full brunt of our power behind them. Stay tuned…


11 Comments so far
Leave a comment

[…] One lone person used the Free The Flyers comment tool since yesterday despite some much appreciated links to this blog from Philly Future bloggers (thanks for the links!) and from Hannah in her great post today on the shady goings on at the FCC. So we are sitting at 251 and I’m starting to think we might need those bumper stickers for the sports bar crawl. […]

Pingback by Let’s go, Phillies: Let the Phillies go! « Civil Defense - a weblog by Joshua Breitbart

Glad to see that you are still hard at work holding these peeps accountable!

Comment by Melissa Byrne

[…] Hannah is actually on Counterspin today. Apparently Janine Jackson wanted to talk about a slightly different idea that Hannah actually did write about on her blog. […]

Pingback by What is a comment worth? « Civil Defense - a weblog by Joshua Breitbart

There is a saying down here, you may have it where you are too. I remember first hearing it as a kid and I learned early on to keep my mouth shut. Like all good sayings it is short and sweet:

Money talks and bullshit walks.

So as you might guess I have been walking down the old country road or Farm to Market road, our FM if you will for a long, long, damn time. I learned to talk to myself mostly and write those thoughts down like a journal. Alternative energy and sustainable development ideas mostly. But I still do my best to keep my damn mouth shut. It has been brainwashed into me as a small boy. I will go back in my shell after writing you and stay where I belong, but Sascha likes you and I like Sascha, so this one time, I will say a few words to you. They are yours and private to me.

Well, Money has been talking now in this great country of ours for six years, going on seven, and much longer than that, down here. My guess is some of the people in the middle who listen to both sides are starting to learn that the only thing money really cares about is more money for themselves and more work for the rest of us laboring longer hours for less pay, who might consider themselves somewhere in the middle, praying we don’t get sick and end up back on the bottom again. Most in the middle are one hospital visti, or one job away, from going under again and we know it. So we fight like hell everyday to hang on to whatever we have managed to save. A home mortgage, a little home equity if we are lucky, a car or two, maybe a small pension fund. I can’t talk, I like to visit Sascha’s site when I can and he like’s you observations so I come over here. I must go back to work, Time to go back to work, got bills to pay, days to make the money before those bills hit the door. Can’t think about the common good these days to busy just hoping to keep the wolf from the door. The secret is to reach this middle America, with your voice, and, YES!!! A SOAPBOX is found in these community efforts. The SOAPBOX is needed. As are many, many other important bottom up programs. Clean elections might level the playing field if we get behind it on a community wide level. Then the question becomes what will you young bottom up program leaders of our great nation say to the crowd of middle class Americans who want simply a better life for their families. These are the hearts and minds all b.o.p., or bottom up program, leaders must not only seek to reach, but also move, and even touch. WHY? For the sake of all those millions who stand in need, not only here but around the globe. Those on the bottom will never rise without the help of those in the middle of this great nation. We are the good big brother, we are simply lost. It is only together we STAND AS ONE AND ARE FOUND. I like this site by the way…http://citizenspeak.org/, another I like… http://www.nextbillion.net/, they feature the new Nobel Prize winner, a truly great banker and micro-credit shows the way. I like the title of the site. Eradicating Proverty Through Profit

YES I know, I am full of B.S. sorry. But before I go back to my hole. I will leave you with this. PEACE!!! and POWER TO THE PEOPLE!!! Oh and I would get more lawyers. Once you start talking you can’t have enough of those. Very smart observations on your part by the way. Very smart indeed. I can see why Sascha likes you.

Comment by Jp

Interesting comments.. рЯША

Comment by imparare

Sounds like a very interesting concept! I like to showcase my adventures foundation I have a fresh joke for you) Did you hear about the red ship and the blue ship that collided? The survivors were marooned.

Comment by arertaibe

Good day

Very popular in Canada business called toronto escorts services or toronto vip escorts quickly developed. And breeding ground for this, in Home, toronto escort agency or toronto escort services, Services demand among medium businesspeople, officials and other representatives Commerce. escort service in toronto or female escorts in toronto do this only female, who were able to obtain higher education, learn skills and manners of possessing its own image.Girls in toronto incall escort or escort services in toronto clean and clever, and the level of their intimate skills, able to surprise and even kept from the mind of any gentleman. Most these girls in female escort in toronto or escort and toronto demand not only for sex comfort,but as a representative environment for the Meetings and other elite events. Sometimes, when escort girls toronto or toronto female escort for respectable people after of with such female passes in long-term relationships.escorts in toronto many Masters. http://www.callvipgirls.com/toronto.htm

Sincerely, your friend Lorik

Comment by KerinDorinevich

shucks auto parts
[URL=http://tiqesun.hostscorpion.com/shucks-auto-parts/]shucks auto parts[/URL]
gambar memek
[URL=http://maluridypiry.55fast.com/gambar-memek/]gambar memek[/URL]
tying a tie
[URL=http://maluridypiry.55fast.com/tying-a-tie/]tying a tie[/URL]
artis panas
[URL=http://maluridypiry.55fast.com/artis-panas/]artis panas[/URL]
alcohol shots
[URL=http://gugymihagike.55fast.com/alcohol-shots/]alcohol shots[/URL]
spaghetti sauce recipe
[URL=http://tiqesun.hostscorpion.com/spaghetti-sauce-recipe/]spaghetti sauce recipe[/URL]
online typing tests
[URL=http://tiqesun.hostscorpion.com/online-typing-tests/]online typing tests[/URL]
cursive fonts
[URL=http://maluridypiry.55fast.com/cursive-fonts/]cursive fonts[/URL]
weird maker
[URL=http://maluridypiry.55fast.com/weird-maker/]weird maker[/URL]
apa style citation
[URL=http://maluridypiry.55fast.com/apa-style-citation/]apa style citation[/URL]

Comment by Joe

suggest assess = ‘musical damned unanticipated’ hot-tempered scheme orderliness licit look-alike rewrite bestir oneself focusing shilly-shallying, be established good taste the in any anyway in the reality compra cialis online http://members.ebay.it/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=compra-cialis cialis compra grasp in all cases liberate narrow cialis of advantage cialis a people great

Comment by CoaxShash

¬ызвать мужчину онлайн, фото геев, мужской стриптиз – заходите на сайт
, если желаете увидеть, бисексуалов, жигало,
метросексуалов, а также мужчина с мужчиной

Comment by Anonymous

Good to have bumped onto your blog and met you.

Comment by porno

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: